The violence is fake, the impact is real

In The Violence Is Fake, The Impact Is Real, Ellen Goodman looks at the impact of television violence on children back in 1977. She criticizes the broadcasters because the only think that matters for them is how to make a profit. They ignore the consequences of violence on the children. She talks about the studies that the government released about this problem, in which the expected conclusion is that violence on the television does lead to aggressive behavior by children and teenagers who watch the programs. She compares the protests of the broadcast with those of the cigarette manufactures who deny the link between cigarettes and lung disease. The same, televisions, refuse to accept that an increasing number of violent behaviors of children, have something in common with their shows.

In 1977, there were no regularly scheduled programs for kids on any networks and most of the programs the children watch were adult television. For the broadcasters, the more violent is the problem, the more excited is the audiences. On television, the children see the violence in terms of excitement because there is no feeling badly about violence; there is nothing to show the consequences of the violence. That s why the children will deduce violence as a normal and accepting thing. In the end, kids may be less affected by the presence of violence than by the absence of pain. They learn that violence is okay, that nobody gets hurt.

The author mentions the unwritten rule in Japan, that if you show violence on television, you have to show the results of that violence and she agrees with this method saying that maybe that s what s missing. In the real world, people repress aggression because they know the consequences, but on television there are no consequences, that s why children learn to accept violence not knowing how bed the consequences might be.

This essay is over twenty years old and today children are watching even more television than ever. I think that Goodman s claims are still important today, because kids are still exposed to violence on television and the problem is yet to be solved. From cartoons to documentaries, violence is used to captivate the attention of viewers, many of them, being innocent children. Young children are exposed to television violence mostly through cartoons and the cartoon heroes. The images they see on TV will help create an idea how they have to act, and more violent images may contribute to more aggression.

...